You are here  : Home News Insurance Update
The News
Williams v Dolin
Date

15/09/2000

The Issues

Whether a party should be entitled to claim costs at a fast track trial having failed to lodge its statement of costs in time.

The Facts

Road traffic accident - allocated to the fast track - Claimant awarded just under �5000 in damages. Claimant had failed to serve a costs schedule in accordance with the Civil Procedure Rules and no explanation was offered to save "possible administrative oversight". Defendant contended that that explanation did not satisfy the test of exceptional circumstances and invited Judge to make no order as to costs.

The Decision

Claimant should be limited to the recovery of Counsel's brief fee plus VAT, the issue fee and the fee for preparing the medical report. All other costs disallowed. The rule in the practice direction was clear. The Claimants Solicitor had had ample opportunity to become acquainted with it.

 
Harris v Perry (1) Perry (2) Harris (3) High Court 8th May 2008

Harris v Perry (1) Perry (2) Harris (3) High Court 8th May 2008

Date

09/06/2008

The Issues

Supervision of children - bouncy castle - whether level of supervision of children at party was adequate.

The Facts

The Claimant was a minor born in June 1994. The First and Second Defendants were husband and wife who organised a party for their triplet's 10th birthday on 10th September 2005. They hired a bouncy castle and the bungee run and put it on a playing field behind their house. The playing field was open to the public. The Third Defendant, Mr Harris, was the Claimant's father who organised, on the same day as the party, a regular football training session for youngsters on the same field. The Claimant was one of fifteen boys of a similar age attending that training session.

Read more... [Harris v Perry (1) Perry (2) Harris (3) High Court 8th May 2008]